Fundraising
Nonprofit Accounting
Nonprofit Donor Management
Nonprofit Management
Nonprofit KPIs: The Financial and Fundraising Metrics Boards Should Track, With a Scorecard
Last updated: October 12, 2026 · Independent guide · We do not sell rankings or coverage.
The nonprofit KPIs a board should track fall into two groups: financial health metrics (months of operating reserves, liquidity ratio, days cash on hand, program expense ratio and grant revenue concentration) and fundraising metrics (cost per dollar raised, donor retention rate and average gift). Each one has a fixed formula, and every input comes from three places you already have: the statement of activities and balance sheet in your accounting system, the Form 990, and your donor CRM. The scorecard below gives each formula, its source line and a published reference point.
How to use this template
Copy the first table into a spreadsheet or board packet and keep the formulas fixed from quarter to quarter. Fill the financial rows from your close, check year-end figures against the Form 990 lines shown, and pull the fundraising rows from your CRM for the same fiscal period. The second table is a completed illustration for checking your arithmetic.
The nonprofit KPI scorecard
| KPI | Formula | Where the inputs live | Published reference point |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Months of operating reserves | (Net assets without donor restrictions − (net fixed assets − debt secured by them)) ÷ ((total expenses − depreciation) ÷ 12) | Balance sheet; Form 990 Part X lines 27, 10c, 23; Part IX line 25 column (A) and line 22 | At least 3 months (25% of expenses) at the year’s low point (Operating Reserves Initiative Workgroup) |
| 2. Liquidity ratio (current ratio) | Current assets ÷ current liabilities | Classified balance sheet; liquidity and availability note in audited statements | No published sector standard; track the trend |
| 3. Days cash on hand | Unrestricted cash and current investments ÷ ((annual expenses − depreciation, in-kind, pass-through and one-time costs) ÷ 365) | Bank and investment balances; Form 990 Part X lines 1 and 2; Part IX lines 22 and 25 | 52% of surveyed nonprofits held 3 months or less (Nonprofit Finance Fund, 2025) |
| 4. Program expense ratio | Program service expenses ÷ total functional expenses | Statement of functional expenses; Form 990 Part IX line 25, column (B) ÷ column (A) | At least 65% (BBB Wise Giving Alliance Standard 8) |
| 5. Cost per dollar raised | Fundraising expenses ÷ contributions, gifts and grants | Form 990 Part IX line 25 column (D) ÷ Part VIII line 1h; statement of activities | No more than $0.35 (BBB Wise Giving Alliance Standard 9) |
| 6. Donor retention rate | Donors who gave last year and again this year ÷ all donors who gave last year | Donor CRM (retained and lapsed donor reports) | 43.3% across the sector in 2025 (Fundraising Effectiveness Project) |
| 7. Average gift | Total dollars from gifts ÷ number of gifts in the same period | Donor CRM, reconciled to contribution revenue | Your own prior year |
| 8. Grant revenue concentration | Revenue from your largest funder (or largest revenue type) ÷ total revenue | Funder dimension in the ledger; Form 990 Part VIII lines 1e and 12 | No published threshold; the board sets a ceiling |
Completed scorecard (illustration). The figures below belong to a fictional organization with $2,500,000 of revenue and $2,400,000 of expenses. They show the arithmetic only and are not benchmarks.
| KPI | Illustrative inputs | Result | Example board threshold |
|---|---|---|---|
| Months of operating reserves | ($1,150,000 − ($420,000 − $150,000)) ÷ ($2,340,000 ÷ 12 = $195,000) | 4.5 months | Green at 3 months or more |
| Liquidity ratio | $900,000 ÷ $360,000 | 2.5 | Amber below 1.5 |
| Days cash on hand | $610,000 ÷ ($2,340,000 ÷ 365 = $6,411) | 95 days | Green at 90 days or more |
| Program expense ratio | $1,872,000 ÷ $2,400,000 | 78.0% | Review if below 65% |
| Cost per dollar raised | $216,000 ÷ $1,350,000 | $0.16 | Review if above $0.35 |
| Donor retention rate | 516 ÷ 1,200 prior-year donors | 43.0% | Up 2 points year over year |
| Average gift | $540,000 ÷ 2,000 gifts | $270 | Flat or rising versus prior year |
| Grant revenue concentration | $480,000 ÷ $2,500,000 | 19.2% | Amber above 25% from one funder |
The thresholds in the last column are examples; replace them with limits your finance committee approves. Only the 3-month, 65% and 35% figures come from published guidance.
How to fill in each part of the scorecard
1. Months of operating reserves
The Nonprofit Operating Reserves Initiative Workgroup defines operating reserves as available net assets without donor restrictions, excluding equity in buildings and equipment (fixed assets net of the debt that financed them). It suggests a starting minimum of 25% of the annual expense budget, or three months, measured at the lowest point of the year rather than at year-end (Operating Reserves Initiative Workgroup, December 2008). If cash dips every summer before a fall campaign, report that month as well as the quarter-end.
2. Liquidity ratio
The current ratio shows whether assets that turn into cash within 12 months cover bills due in the same period (Propel Nonprofits, no date shown). Under ASU 2016-14, audited statements also disclose the financial assets available for general expenditures within one year of the balance sheet date (Journal of Accountancy, December 5, 2018). Use that figure as a cross-check, because a high current ratio can hide restricted or slow-paying pledges.
3. Days cash on hand
Propel Nonprofits removes depreciation, in-kind, pass-through and one-time expenses before dividing annual expenses by 365, and says the right target depends on how reliable your income is. The Nonprofit Finance Fund’s 2025 survey of 2,206 nonprofits found 52% held three months of cash or less and 18% one month or less (Nonprofit Finance Fund, June 17, 2025). Count only cash the board can spend.
4. Program expense ratio
Form 990 Part IX splits every expense into column (B) program service, column (C) management and general and column (D) fundraising, with totals on line 25 (IRS, Form 990 (2025)). ASU 2016-14 requires the same functional split in GAAP statements. The BBB Wise Giving Alliance asks charities to spend at least 65% of total expenses on programs (BBB Wise Giving Alliance, last modified May 12, 2026). The ratio depends on how you allocate shared costs such as rent, so document the method.
5. Cost per dollar raised
Divide Part IX line 25 column (D) by Part VIII line 1h, which totals all contributions including government grants and event contributions. BBB Standard 9 caps fundraising at 35% of related contributions, or $0.35 per dollar. Check that fees to outside fundraisers on Part IX line 11e are included. A falling figure can also mean you cut donor acquisition, which shows up in retention a year later.
6. Donor retention rate
The Fundraising Effectiveness Project, run by the AFP Foundation for Philanthropy and GivingTuesday with data from donor software providers, reported retention of 43.3% for 2025, up from 43.1%, while donor counts fell an estimated 3.6% (AFP, April 21, 2026). The Q1 2026 report put retention at 18.0% for giving in January through March only, so compare a full-year rate only to the annual figure (AFP, July 29, 2026). Bloomerang, a CRM vendor that contributes data, summarizes FEP results as roughly 20% retention for first-time donors and 60% for repeat donors (Bloomerang, September 15, 2026), so report the two separately.
7. Average gift
Calculate it from CRM gift records, not the ledger, and show grants and large bequests separately. Pair it with donor count: in Q1 2026 the FEP found dollars up an estimated 4.3% while donors fell 0.8%, so a rising average gift can mask a shrinking donor base.
8. Grant revenue concentration
Propel Nonprofits calls this the reliance ratio (largest income type divided by total income) and also tracks government grants and contracts as a share of income. Track your largest single funder too. The NFF survey found 84% of respondents with government funding expected cuts, so review this ratio at the same meeting as cash and reserves.
Where to find peer benchmarks
For financial ratios, the most direct peer data is other organizations’ Form 990s. The IRS Tax Exempt Organization Search lets you search Form 990 series returns and download bulk data files (IRS, no date shown), and ProPublica’s Nonprofit Explorer lets you search and download filings, with XML data for e-filed returns (ProPublica, September 23, 2026). Pick five to ten peers of similar size and mission and calculate the same Form 990 ratios for each.
Common mistakes
- Mixing restricted and unrestricted money. Propel advises using unrestricted assets only; a restricted campaign balance can inflate reserves by months.
- Measuring at year-end only. A figure taken right after a spring gala can overstate your low point.
- Mismatched retention windows. Bloomerang defaults to a rolling window while boards often expect a fiscal year. Pick one and set the CRM to match.
- Unreconciled CRM totals. Reconcile gift totals to contribution revenue each month before reporting average gift.
When to move from a spreadsheet to software
A spreadsheet works while one person compiles the scorecard quarterly. Once you need monthly updates, drill-down to transactions or shared numbers, build the KPIs into your accounting system and CRM. Our guides to nonprofit accounting software and donor management software compare wider options.
QuickBooks Online. Class tracking in Plus and Advanced tags transactions by program, management and general, or fundraising, under Settings > Account and settings > Advanced > Categories (Intuit, August 3, 2026). The Advanced Performance center under Reports offers up to 25 charts, one metric each, from a list of 10 metrics that includes the current ratio but not reserves or cost per dollar raised (Intuit, no fixed date shown, checked October 12, 2026), so reserves and cost per dollar raised stay in a spreadsheet. See signs it is time to replace QuickBooks.
Sage Intacct. Dashboard performance cards can use computational account groups, so ratios such as months of reserves live in the system with prior-period or budget comparisons (Sage Intacct, October 8, 2026). Statistical accounts track nonfinancial data such as headcount, so they can also hold donor or gift counts from your CRM (Sage Intacct, October 8, 2026), and user-defined dimensions can represent funders (Sage Intacct, October 8, 2026). Our Sage Intacct for nonprofits guide covers pricing and setup.
Bloomerang. The home dashboard’s Donor Retention tile recalculates daily, links to Lapsed and Retained Donors reports, and can be switched from a rolling year to fiscal or calendar year (Bloomerang, August 6, 2026). It covers the fundraising rows only.
Salesforce Nonprofit Cloud. The DonorGiftSummary object stores first and last gift dates, gift count, total amount and RFM scores per donor (Salesforce, no date shown, Winter ’27 documentation). It has no built-in retained or lapsed flag, so an administrator or partner must build retention reports from the date fields.
How we researched this
We reviewed the top-ranking “nonprofit KPIs” pages from Neon One, NetSuite and insightsoftware, all software sellers; none mapped inputs to Form 990 lines or cited published standards such as the BBB Wise Giving Alliance thresholds. Formulas come from the Operating Reserves Initiative Workgroup and Propel Nonprofits, line numbers from the 2025 Form 990, and product details from vendor documentation checked in October 2026.
Related guides
- Statement of Activities: Nonprofit Template and How-To
- Statement of Functional Expenses: Template and How-To
- SYBUNT and LYBUNT Reports: Find Lapsed Donors
Frequently asked questions
What are the most important KPIs for a nonprofit board?
For financial health, track months of operating reserves, days cash on hand, a liquidity ratio and the program expense ratio. For fundraising, add cost per dollar raised, donor retention and average gift, plus grant revenue concentration to show exposure to one funder.
How many months of operating reserves should a nonprofit have?
The Nonprofit Operating Reserves Initiative Workgroup suggests a minimum of three months, or 25% of annual expenses, measured at the lowest point of the year. It presents this as a starting point, not a universal rule.
What is a good donor retention rate?
The Fundraising Effectiveness Project reported sector-wide retention of 43.3% for 2025. First-time donors are retained at much lower rates than repeat donors, so track the two separately. The most useful comparison is your own rate against last year.
How do you calculate the program expense ratio from Form 990?
Divide Part IX line 25 column (B), program service expenses, by line 25 column (A), total functional expenses. The BBB Wise Giving Alliance standard is at least 65%. Keep your shared-cost allocation method consistent between years.
Sources
- Nonprofit Operating Reserves Initiative Workgroup, operating reserves white paper, December 2008.
- Propel Nonprofits, “Analyzing Financial Information Using Ratios”, no date shown.
- IRS, Form 990 (2025), form year 2025.
- IRS, Instructions for Form 990 (2025), tax year 2025.
- Journal of Accountancy, coverage of FASB ASU 2016-14, December 5, 2018.
- BBB Wise Giving Alliance, Standards for Charity Accountability, last modified May 12, 2026.
- Nonprofit Finance Fund, 2025 State of the Nonprofit Sector Survey announcement, June 17, 2025.
- AFP, Fundraising Effectiveness Project Q4 2025 report, April 21, 2026.
- AFP, Fundraising Effectiveness Project Q1 2026 report, July 29, 2026.
- Bloomerang, Donor retention (vendor page), September 15, 2026.
- Bloomerang Help, Donor Retention Wheel basics, August 6, 2026.
- Intuit, Set up class tracking, August 3, 2026.
- Intuit, Create charts to see business performance (Performance center), no fixed date shown, checked October 12, 2026.
- Sage Intacct Help, Dashboard basics, October 8, 2026.
- Sage Intacct Help, Track statistical data overview, October 8, 2026.
- Sage Intacct Help, Dimensions overview, October 8, 2026.
- Salesforce, Nonprofit Cloud Developer Guide: DonorGiftSummary, no date shown (Winter ’27, API 68.0).
- IRS, Tax Exempt Organization Search, no date shown.
- ProPublica, Nonprofit Explorer, September 23, 2026.
Sherman Hsieh
Independent analysis of enterprise software — ERP, CRM and more
